GNOSIS takes majority of SG, NSA positionsAlthough there are several were cast in the College; the re- Taylor (GNOSIS) 341 Pierce (Liberal) 113 Totman (GNOSIS)..Spanle (GNOSIS) ...340 Tauss (Liberal) 107 Weis berg (GNOSIS)graduate Larson (GNOSIS) 330 Haven (Liberal) 106 Huyck (POLIT)ties for Assembly seats and maining 447, in theseveral SG and NSA candi- schools and divisions. This year’s sag* ' vote represents about 55% of thp Ray ™polSt?LIT) 322dates have requested re¬counts, GNOSIS won a clear ma¬jority of SG and NSA positions inlast week’s elections.GNOSIS candidates won at least22 of 33 graduate SG seats andeight out of 18 College seats.POLIT, which has had an SG majority since its founding two years with fewer than twenty votes._ „ » Ray (POLIT) 320College enrollment, and 15% of Komesar (gnosis) 319the graduate enrollment. l$Son(<< GNOSIS j!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! fnCollege representatives needed Magidson (independ.t 307322 votes to win this year, as com- 'pared to 289 last year. On the other Mahoney (polit) !!!!!!!*.!!!!!!ill!!294hand, no graduates who were *elected received more than 68 Tolbert (gnosis* 283votes, and several were elected Kaplan (polit) 267 DIVISIONSBiological SciencesGrabaritis (Write-in GNOSIS) 14Gold (POLIT) 5Roth (POLIT) 5HumanitiesPlaegstrom (GNOSIS) 35Brannon (GNOSIS) 35Elwood (GNOSIS) 27Lyons (GNOSIS) 19Klenbort (POLIT) 11Mazelis (POLIT) 10Physical SciencesFinder (GNOSIS) 37Richards (GNOSIS) 33Hill (GNOSIS) 3?Sumner (GNOSIS) 3 2Kay (POLIT) 267ago, won only nine undergraduate Pamela Procuniar (POLIT) re- Jaffee (POLIT).....! 263and six graduate seats. The Liberal ceived the largest number of votes. 5UParty won the remaining College both in the College (681) and for Stephens (GNC^ IS j!!!!! 1! *. *.!!!! .*!!!! »5seat and the Law School Party NSA (836). She led in the College Rphbins (Liberal) 238 schacher (POLITj .*!!! J .23 B . ,¥Vo,W—Jwon the three Law School grad- by over 175 votes and in NSA by wSdby (LuS?.' !!!!!!!!!!!! .*!!!!! .‘S G^Stein^POLrrj n ^ i!!!!! i! i! i!!:!!!!!!!!uate seats. about 70. Miss Procuniar was the Hirschhorn (politj 224 Kinney (Lsp> «iLibrary—1five delegates and alternates po *" icvncici mo Rera-er fPoi.iTr .j 59 (tie)Shields (POLIT)Schlotthauer (GNOSIS)PROFESSIONAL SCHOOLSBusiness—3Beal (GNOSIS) 46Pipin (GNOSIS) 45Bailey (GNOSIS) 42Divinity—2(GNOSIS) S(tie)Tyree (Write-in) 1Black (Write-in) 1Wallen (Write-in) 1Williamson (Write-in) 1Education—1Trimberger (GNOSIS) 6Law—3Hartmant xto a nv.Ar.Tt, . . , cr, ... , stein (Liberal) 218 Social SciencesIn NSA, GNOSIS won four out only SG representative up for re- Mazen (POLIT) 213 Boyan (polit) 68call in January who was kept in Van Wormer (GNOSIS) 199 Berger (POLIT) ./ 59 iofflce- Hattis (Liberal) 159 Gilbert (.POLIT) 55 Paugher <Wnte-in» 1Bob Axelrod, the only candidate Grossman (Liberal) 158 Richter (GNOSIS) 55 Medicine 2from the T ilieral Partv to be Robinson (Liberal) 156 Brownstone (POLIT) 51 Bernstein (GNOSIS) 14from tne Liberal Party to oe wladowsky (Liberal) 153 Carlsten (POLIT) 51 Leavitt (GNOSIS) IIelected, was second m the College Epstein (Liberal) 153 Reber (GNOSIS) 5« cca ?with 503 votes. Axelrod received gss?*8iJS^!::::::::::::::::8S E£^<86sis>::::::::::::::::::« »tile highest number of votes m Nixon (Liberal) 118 Lefton (GNOSIS) 44 Kudriavetz (GNOSIS) 31sitions, with POLIT taking thefifth delegate’s position, and theLiberal Party, the fifth alternate’sposition.The constitutional ammendmentto provide representation in theCollege by residential unit wras ap¬proved by a nearly 2-1 majority:H30-532.Recount and tiesThe newly elected SG Assemblywill hold its first meeting nextTuesday night. At that time, itwill vote to break three graduateseat ties and elect officers andCommittee Chairmen.Ties exist between two POLITcandidates for a seat in the divi¬sion of biological sciences (Eachhas five votes), among four write-in candidates in the Divinity School(Each has one vote), and betweena GNOSIS candidate and a write- mAGii \ Liinvi A.A.W uv-i.vvi> \ _ e.when he Pell (Liberal) 115 Treiman (POLIT) 44 Richards (POLIT) .21the College last year,ran as an independent.Axelrod said that the membersof the Liberal Party plan to runa disarmament conference and aseminar series and to participatein SG committee activities. Heestimated that his party has aboutten active members who will work.The most successful GNOSIScandidate was Jerry Hyman, whoreceived 492 votes in the College.Bruce Rappaport and Peter Rab-inowitz (both POLIT) were theonly other two candidates in theCollege to receive more than 400votes. —Miss Procuniar was the only ^as scheduled to speak at FOTAcandidate in the College •« cVal. 71 — No. 92 University of Chicago, Tuesday, April 16, 1963in tiie college or inNSA to receive a majority of allin candidate in the Graduate Li¬brary School (Each has one vote). ^Tes castBallots for the winners receiving The number of votes receivedtiie fewest votes for SG and NSA by each candidate is given below:will be recounted this evening. *.e. ...The NSA recounting will be „ NSA Delegatesdone on behalf of POUT eandi- Jerry Hyman (gnosis) 761 edllled to appear in the Festl- Stanford and Indiana.Yevtushenko cancels US tourRussian poet Yevgeny Yev- was scheduled for May 11. He was The “poignancy of the allair, hetushenko, who had been sched- supposed to visit 16 Other’ Amen- said, was that “The Soviets knewcan colleges, including Princeton, we WOuld cancel the tourdates Bruce Rappaport, Rarbara S®" 55? val the Arts as part of aCaress, and Dick Jacobson. Rappa- Bev spiane (gnosis) 628port lost in his bid for NSA dele- Bruce Rappaport (POLIT) 621t u , Neil Komesar (GNOSIS) 601gate by seven votes, Jacobson and sally Cook (POLIT) 540Caress missed becoming alternates Terri Ray (POLIT) 479by seven and 14 votes respectively. Andrew ”V 461NSA—Alternates we would cancel tne tour our¬selves, because of the self-imposedtour of the United States, has can-i Rappaport u-uluj ozi pnejKomesar (GNOSIS) 601 CLllen n*s 11 *P-Yevtushenko s wife cabled AlbertTodd at Indiana University, whowas handling the proposed tour. Ac¬cording to Hugh McLean, chair¬man of the UC Slavic department,who handled the arrangements atthis campus, the telegram saidAssembly votes will be recount¬ed m • t, t,at '„ Jerry McBeath (GNOSIS) 572on behalf of lerri Ray, IOLIT, Robert Axelrod (Liberal) 549who missed being elected bv two Tom Hea&y (gnosis) 500Vftiev and T„d„ iu j Terry Peterson (GNOSIS) 499votes, and Judy Magidson (In- Roger Peters (GNOSIS) 482 . -dependent), who lost bv 15 votes Dick Jacobson (POLIT) 475 Yevtushenko was “ill.”Any student who *—»«■ * - Barbara Caress (POLIT) 468 Bob Beck, director of the Festi¬val of the Arts, said the festival deadline.” (The US co-ordinatorscommittee was sorry Yevtushenko had said the tour would be can-could not come to the US at all. celled unless a formal acceptanceand not just that he could not or cancellation was received bycome to UC. last Friday.)Colleges ignore roleThe three primary roles of made thjd the scholar hascandidate in the election may help Joel'YpolitI*.. 424 attacked for his poem “Babi Yar,” the contemporary American ^nm^a'mlrior^riilrbmcount votes Counting Will begin at i!ii!i 1)5 whif Ru^ian officia|s said went college are totally unrelated ati; members of the fac7.30 pm In the SG office, 2nd floor Richard Schmitt (POLIT, 354 too far in denouncing the Stalinists. to liberal education, according’ sindont * niton nfiootoH-was not a Jon Roland (GNOSIS) Yevtushenko has been repeatedlyof Ida Noyes Hall.Total is lowerTliis year’s total vote ofis lower than last year’s, Bernie Groffman (Liberal) 222Larry Robinson (Liberal) 197Bob Haven (Liberal) 1521523 College. , Procuniar (POUT) 681higher than 1961s. Last year, 1283 Hyman (gnosis) 492undergraduates and 780 graduate Rappap®1-* (polit) 453 uwiuuuwu iv. , , , Rabinowltz (polit) 416 biography to a Paris newspaperstudents voted, for a total of 2063. caress (POUT).... 389In 1961, 1483 student votes out of McBeatb (gnosis) 389a total quadrangles enrollment of j'/cobson(Vpout)!.!!!!*.!!..!!!!!!". 380 The most recent attacks havebeen in reaction to a visit toFrance which Yevtushenko made,which was greeted enthusiasticallyby Frenchmen. He was especiallydenounced for releasing his auto- The three primary roles of made thjd the scholar has the abil¬ity to teach and scholarly researchin evalu-„ faculty. Theto liberal education, according student is often affected; he is ex-to S. Ronald Weiner, instructor pected to make an early commit-in the humanities. ment to a specialized field of learn-Weiner, who addressed 40 stu- ing. Efficiency, then, becomes thedents at West House last night, criterion for education,said that colleges today purport Weiner noted with alarm the de-to be either trade schools, finish- humanizing trend ot our culture,ing schools, or preparatory insti- jje described a hypothetical institu-tutions for graduate study. tion which would attempt “to pro-Liberal education, on the other vide education for people and notA Sovie. writers union meetingFriday recommended that “lib-5350 were cost. This year’s enroll- Heagy "gnosisl!!!!!!!!!”!!!!!!!.380 eral writers such as Yevtushenko itself with learning for robots.’ment is about 6000. Golaffi c!.*.*!!!!.*!!!!.’!!!!!56 forbidden 10 travel abroad- and with constructing various1086 of this year’s 1523 votes Kaufman (POLIT)’.Y.. .....!...!.!!.356 Yevtushenko's UC appearance modes of compromise with chaos.It __ences which in themselves have nostructure.Instead of providing a liberaleducation our institutions devotetheir energies to other endeavorsand produce a teaching system He called for the establishmentof “a community of learners indeals with structuring expei i wjdch some people happen to knowHistorian Franklin to join facultyJohn Hope Franklin, an historian and authority on slavery and the Reconstruc¬tion, has been appointed Professor of American History.Although Franklin is now a Professor and oChairman of the Department of His- aiM1 _rililll,._ ^ ^ . .. , . . ..tory at Brooklyn College, New York, he is currently serving as W illiam Pitt Profes- dominated by a school of educa- learn whpn thev want ;n ,Mrn it. . _ _ : — : ~ i: i .. « « faaoliAC Jmore than others.” All membersof this community would engage inboth teaching and learning. Theorganizing principle for the cur¬riculum would be that studentsshould learn what theysor of American History and Insti¬tutions at St. John's College atCambridge, England. He plans toreturn to Brooklyn College beforeassuming his full-time faculty posi¬tion at UC in autumn quarter, 1964.Franklin, a Phi Beta Kappa, wasthe first Negro to be admitted tothe Cosmos Club in Washington,D.C., last December. The club’smember-ship policies re¬received nation-w i d e attentionin 1961 over therejectionof Carl T. Row¬an, then a StateDepartment QfficialAccording toThe New York J- H. FranKunTimes, Frankin’s appointment was that there are five or six Negrofull professors here.Franklin was one of the authorsof the brief submitted to the Su¬preme Court by the NAACP againstschool segregation in 1954. tion, “which generally teaches The curriculum would combinemaximum flexibility with thorough¬ness and allowances for individual39; Guggenheim Fellow, 1950-51;and President’s Fellow at Brown nothing in words of more than oneUniversity, 1952-53. syllable,” he continued. „„„Born in Oklahoma, Franklin re- Weiner pointed out that the dis- differences<ceived his AB from Fisk Univer- tinction between scholarship and ^ addUion to courses in reading,sity in 1935 and his AM (1936) and learning is of ten blurred. Scholar- ^ schoo, wou]d haye reqnircdIn May 1962, President Kennedy PhD (1941) from Harvard Univer- ship, a subset of learning, concerns courses dea|jng three fuiula-appointed Franklin to the Board sity. He has been an instructor in itself with the solution of highly mentaj suj,jects; language or theof Foreign Scholarships for a three history at Fisk University, 1936- technical problems. The American ver^aj arts number and time,year term. His other civic services 37. and professor at St. Augustine’s college often makes the mistake of j,anguaore aild number are fieldswhich attempt to “bring order outof chaos.’’ Studies in time would lieinquiries into the way in whichpeople have thought about tem¬poral order and its implications.The student ivho masters the ma-include memberships in the U.S. College at Durham, 1939-43, North substituting the ego-ideal of schol-National Commission for UNESCO, Carolina College at Durham, 1943- arship for its own ego-ideal,the Board of Directors of the 47; and Howard University, 1947-56. As a result, the assumption isAmerican Council of Human . . . .Rights, and the Board of Directors \jc scientist predicts new particleof the American Council of Learn- . , „ . . . ., . ,ed Societies The existence of an atomic ic weight^falls between that ofThe author of books and articles particle, predicted this past an electron and that of a proton terials presented in these coursesIn both experiments, a beam of would be able to read those booksK-mesons, particles similar to the which, according to Weiner, con-newly discovered ones but bet- stitute the “bloodstream of cul-ter knowm, was aimed at a tank ture.” After two years the studentof liquid hydrogen. Evidence for would be required to write papersthe existence of the new particles on these works.struction: After the Civil War, The " "'V Y , , . came from photographs taken of The courses in Weiner’s collegeMilitant South, and The Emancipa- , r'ie ParVcle» called a phi-meson the prec;se m0ment when the col- would be established by joint stu-tion Proclamation. Sakurai, was predicted in the iis,on 0f the K-mesons and the dent-faculty committees since “aIn addition to his current posi- December l issue of^ Phy*ical Re- ~i,ydroR:en atoms took place. student would learn more from ations as Pitt Professor at Cam- v,ew Letter*- lhe findings veri- experiments found that the poorly organized course which hebridge, Franklin served previously fyinK the Prediction were report- mass of the new particle is ap- helped to establish than from aas Fulbright Professor at Cam- et^ yesterdays issue of the same proximately 1019 electron volts, better course designed by someonebridge and as Distinguished Amer- publication. or roughly 2,000 times heavier else.”ican Fulbright Professor at Aus- The phi-meson is a short-lived than an electron. The lifetime of In the third or fourth year, thetralian National University. His particle created by the bombard- the particle is two ten-thousandths student would be required to sub-other academic honors include ment of an atom with a man-made of one billionth of one billionth mit an essay approximately 150awards as Edward Austin Fellow', beam of particles or by a cosmic of a second. After expiring, it pages long dealing with a topic of1937-38; Rosenwald Fellow, 1937- ray particle from space. Its atom- splits into two K-mesons. particular interest to him.dealing with the various aspects winter by UC physicist Junof the American Negro. Franklin John Sakurai, has been con-has called the Negro “the last rev- firmed by recent experimentsolutionary.” His works include: at the University of California atFrom Slavery to Freedom: A His- Los Angeles and the Brookhavenmade partially because the Uni- tory of American Negroes, Recon- National Laboratories.versity hopes that it will encourage ~Negro intellectuals and make Chi¬cago a center for their research.The article which appeared onSunday also quoted UC ProfessorDaniel J. Boorstin as saying thatthis was a “role that has been un¬filled” in American universities.A spot check of 17 major univer¬sities indicated that 11 have Negroprofessors, but had only one or two.Even though UC records do notmention race, one official guessedEDITORIALConsider election resultsSG elections are over. A newmajority party, which consists pri¬marily of inexperienced, relativelyuninformed members, many ofthem graduate students with bare¬ly enough time to meet the mini¬mal obligations of an SG repre¬sentative, will be responsible forfilling the leadership positions ofSG. Members of the former ma¬jority party forecast the impend¬ing destruction of all that wasgood in both SG and NS A. Andthey may well be right, for a goodnumber of people elected by thecampus are best characterized bytheir lack of adequate qualifica¬tions and preparation for the veryimportant posts they are expectedto fill. In fact, their election maybe the biggest obstacle to achiev¬ing the potential of SG, unlessthey are willing to depart fromtradition.We appeal to all members of SG—especially to all members of thenew majority—to temporarily layaside party affiliations and takestock of themselves and their newcolleagues: to evaluate their fa¬miliarity with campus and SGproblems, and their demonstratedability to get things done.We suggest that such an exami¬nation will reveal the major prob¬lem GNOSIS faces: getting quali¬fied students from its own ranksto fill leadership positions in SG.And we further suggest that inorder to enable SG to functionwith any degree of success in thecoming year, GNOSIS will have tolook beyond its membership forhelp.Wo strongly urge the membersof GNOSIS to do all they can, evenif it means cooperating with the“opposition,’’ to fulfill their re¬sponsibility to the campus of pro¬viding the most capable leadershiplor SG.To those who seek to interpretlast week's vote as an unqualifiedmandate for GNOSIS action and astrong repudiation of POLIT, re¬fusing to give any consideration to©ur suggestion, we would pointout that the small vote in thedivisions and professional schoolswhich produced most of GNOSIS’“strength’’ does not support thisview of the elections. We wouldpoint to the College, which has inthe past, and most likely will inthe future provide most of thelabor and participation in SG.Here, many POLIT candidates re¬ceived far more votes thanGNOSIS candidates. The time has come to create aStudent Government that is farmore concerned w'ith having someeffect on campus than with prop¬agating the glory of the majorityparty, be it POLIT or GNOSIS.And, looking at those studentselected, we would specificallypoint out that representatives likePeter Rabinowtiz, Pamela Pro-cuniar, and Dick Jacobson, eventhough they belong to the “opposi¬tion,” are far more qualified totake positions of responsibility inSG than newcomers like LindaThoren, Ken Taylor, and LynnLarsen. We would hate to see theformer overlooked just becausethey do nol belong to GNOSIS.Granted, we are ignoring politicsto a large extent. But this is be¬cause we believe that SG on thiscampus has enough untapped po¬tential in non-political campusfields, particularly student-facultyrelations and curriculum, that po¬litical party affiliation will notsubstantially alter the ability of arepresentative to work. And sincethe parties seem to us to be infundamental agreement on a num¬ber of campus projects, only thebest people need be given theresponsibility to carry them out.It is not necessary for the inex¬perienced to gain experience atthe expense of SG’s effectiveness.One final comment: we wouldsuggest that SG turn its attentionquickly to the preposterous situ¬ation relating to graduate studentsand SG. When a mere 447 studentscan fill 33 seats by their voteswhile 1086 others can fill only 18others, and when some of theformer seats are given to studentswho receive as few as ten voteswhile no one receiving any of thelatter receives less than 322, some¬thing is terribly wrong with thesystem.Yes, graduate students do havea stake in Student Government,but we cannot help but wonderhow much of a stake, and howmuch time and interest they caneven be expected to contribute.Could not their role. be put morein proportion with their actual andpotential participation? Is it rightthat 33 out of 51 representativesbe students who at most attendSG meetings, while the other 18actually do most of the work?Last year’s .restructure proposalwas defeated. It is not too soonto start preparing one for nextyear.HOBBY HOUSERESTAURANTOpen Dawn to DawnBREAKFAST DINNERLUNCH SNACKS~ 1342 E. 53rd St.TELEPHONE FAirfax 4-9713BROWN'S BARBER SHOPAIR CONDITIONED FOR YOUR COMFORTHENRY K. BROWN, Prop.1011 EAST 53rd STREETCHICAGO 15. ILL.RANDELL.HARPER SQUAREBEAUTY AND COSMETIC SALONOPEN EVENINGS5700 HARPER AVE. FA 4-2007MRS. BILLIE TREGANZA. PROP. Critic hits RabinowitzDEAR MR. RABINOWITZ:In reference to your column ofApril 9th, I feel compelled to ex¬press my profound admiration ofyour writing ability. In the courseof 350 words, not only were youable to say absolutely nothing, butyou were also reasonably success¬ful in hiding the fact that you didnot attend the performance at all.I congratulate you. Not once wasI able to find a single line ofobjective criticism.It is indeed rewarding to knowthat, along with perhaps one-quarter of the world’s population,you consider the Matthew Passionto be, “. . . one of the mightiestmonuments of music.” But yourcomment says nothing about whyit is a great work of art, or abouthow the choir brought about itsfullest expression as a work ofart; and to do this is certainly theobligation of any competent cri¬tic.In the very same sentence yougo to the trouble to make it quiteclear that you are not a competentcritic. You say, and I quote, 44 . . .I have never before been able tosit through a performance (of thePassion) without the vague feeling. . . that I was on the verge of be¬ing bored stiff.” I would like tosubmit that it is impossible foranyone to have a basic understand¬ing of any part of the Passionand still have any feeling of thesort you describe.It is clear from this statementalone that you lack the basic mu¬sical understanding necessary fora critic. But this is not your onlytalent. You also lack scholarshipand sensitivity. You say: “Theorchestra was at it best (boastingsome exquisite oboe solos by RayStill).” This is true enough; theorchestra played reasonably wellas a whole. But Ray Still is notan oboe player, he is a cello play¬er, and beside that, Ray Still wasnot even present on Sunday.Yet farther down in the column was a statement showing yourcomplete lack of sensitivity andgood critical standards: u . . . his(The Tenor’s) few shaky pitchesand weak entrances can be ex¬cused because of the length of hisrole.” From wThere I was sitting Icould have counted twenty orthirty “shaky pitches.” After theperformance, I talked with manypeople, including members of thechoir, who wrould agree with thiscount. Since when have profes¬sional musicians been excused forso many mistakes because of thelength of their parts?^ our standards, sensitivity, un¬derstanding, and writing abilityare all of an unbelievably lowquality. They are not worthy ofpublication in the Maroon. I sug¬gest that in the future the Maroonstaff might do better to select, atrandom, any Humanities One Stu¬dent to write its music criticism.ROBERT SWANRabinowitz hits cricicTO THE EDITOR:Mr. Swan nas several argumentsagainst me: First, I say nothing inthe course of a review and I havea “lack of . . . critical standards.”Second. I am incompetent becauseI am bored by most performancesof the Saint Matthew Passion;finally, I lack scholarship.From the letter, one learns thatwhen Mr. Swan claims that I saynothing, he means that I have neg¬lected the two bases of any 350word review: first, an explanationof why the Passion is a great workof art (a task akin to “Write aboutHamlet in 25 words or less”) andsecond, “objective criticism” basedon “good critical standards.”Out of context, the terms “ob¬jective criticism” and “criticalstandards” are meaningless. Luck¬ily, Mr. Swan gives examples ofwhat he means. If I understandhim, the critic should count theerrors of each performer, set¬ting up a grading system like**G0CA CCi>‘ * AND "COM" ARE RC6I9TEAIO fftADf •«*•*« WHICM <0#courses.... ughregister... rushstand... wait.«shuff le... go...twitch... fidget... yawn... stopmove... nearernearer... filled...pausefake a break•. .things go betterwith CokeNUI I>*n «Bottled under the authority ofThe Coca-Cola Company by:Coca-Cola lottling Co. of Chicago 3-5 wrong notes, A; 6-9 wrongnotes, B; etc.Sw an claims that he “could havecounted twenty or thirty” errorsby the tenor. How could he knowthat he could have counted thatmany without actually countingthem? I hope my vision of his sit¬ting and counting errors, markingthem in a little black notebook andgrading each performer, is wrong;I doubt it, though.Mr. Swan next submits that 1 amincompetent because I get boredafter listening to hours of verysimilar, yet beautiful, music. Thisgets into the problem of taste,which is too complex to be dis¬cussed here. 1 might suggest, how¬ever, that anyone so blindly de¬voted to Bach that he refuses torecognize even his few faults (inthis case, exorbitant length) mightdo well to listen to some othercomposers in order to get a clear¬er, more rational view of Bach.I might also suggest that per¬haps the reason why Mr. Swan wasnot bored was that instead of lis¬tening to the music, he was glee¬fully counting errors. And he's inthe choir, too.As to my scholarship, I mightinform the infallible Mr. Swan thatRay Still is (and has been, for aslong as I can remember) (whichis about a year) the first oboist ofthe Chicago Symphony. I mightsuggest that Swan’s way of mak¬ing up facts to prove others wrongis not quite cricket.For the edification of Mr Swan,I shall attempt to explain what 1was doing in the review. Havingcome from a performance of thePassion which changed my attitudetoward the w’ork, I decided that thebest way of describing the eventwas to dw-ell as little as possibleupon the technical aspects of themusic and instead to describe myattitude upon arriving at the con¬cert and that upon leaving.I hoped that the readers wouldbe able to get from this some ideaof the nature of the performance,on a level somewhat higher thanthat of right and wrong notes. IfMr. Swan feels that I did not suc¬ceed in this attempt (which I liketo call subjective criticism andwhich was not even discussed inhis letter), he should have said so.A letter to a critic can be veryhelpful if it provides a differentreaction to the event in question orif it gives him some idea as U>whether he has achieved what hehas tried to achieve. When a lettermerely tells him that he has notdone what he has not tried to do,it is rather unenlightening.the letter also includes graveifications of fact (as aboutl), and entirely unfounded state-its which merely attempt to de~de the critic (such as the state-nt that I was not at the cont), it proves that the author oiletter is incapable of rationalmission on a civilized, intellec-L level.PETE RABINOWITZIn addition to Books, Type¬writers, Tape Recordersand Photographic supplies,see our stock of SchoolSupplies, Stationery, Gifts,Novelties, Men's and Wom¬en's Wear, Snacks and To¬bacco.THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGOBOOKSTORE5802 ELLIS AVE.2 • CHICAGO MAROON • April 16, 1963CULTURE CALENDARCoberetsHoyt Axton and The ContemporaryFolk Group, folk-singers at the Gateof Horn, 1036 N. State, SU 7-2833.DanceChicago Contemporary Dance Theatre,two UC undergraduates performing,Carole Laudenschalger and Judith Lich-enstein, Eleventh Street Theatre, 72 E.Eleventh Street, HA 7-5670, adm. $1.80,$2.40, and $3.60, April 18, 19, 20, 21,8:30 pm.Exhibits66th Annual Exhibition by Artists ofChicago and Vicinity, at the Art Insti¬tute through June 2.Contemporary Japanese prints, at theArt Institute starting April 19.Recent Paintings by Howard Strass-man, through April 20, Midway Studios.Master Prints of Six Centuries, fromthe Art Institute Collection,Robie House Tours, Saturdays 10 amto 4 pm, Sundays 1 to 5 pm, adra. $1.Films“Rain,” Joan Crawford and WalterHuston, Roosevelt University, SinhaHall, room 785, 430 S. Michigan Ave.,adm $3.50, April 17, 7:30 pm.“Coming Shortly, A Cavalcade ofAmerican Serials, Le Bijou, City with¬ out Wheels, Uirapuru,” Art Institute,Fullerton Hall, 50c adm., April 18,8 pm.“Attila,” at International House onFriday 8 pm.LecturesMaking Forms in Space, Louise Beck,Art Institute, April 16, 12:15 pm.“An American Contradiction: WilliamFaulkner,” Ganz Hall, 430 S. MichiganAve., admission $1.25. April 17, 7-9 pm.The Painters Search for Utopia, An-alee Hultgren, Art Institute, April 19,12:15 pm.“Arts Alive”—panel discussion ofjazz, panel members: Howard Brofsky,Sid McCoy, Barbara Gardner, Don DeMichael, Hyde Park Art Center, 5236S. Blackstone, April 21, 8:30 pm.The New Landscape Vision: Constableand Turners, Esther Seaver Bume, ArtInstitute, April 21, 3:30 pm.“From the Midway, Nuclear Powerand Human Existence” Hans J. Mor-g^nthau, WFMF, April 21, 11 am.Music Brahms, Hindemith, Rudolph Ganz Re¬cital Hall, 430 S. Michigan Ave., free. Sergei prize givenUC aw&rded this year’s and aimed at a higher level of ad-Chieago Mus^cal CoU^ge^Roosevelt *Uni- Sergei Prize for original un- venture and perception than theversity, April is, 8:15 pm. published and unproduced others.”plays to Herbert LiebermanChicago Symphony Orchestra, Ros¬sini, Brahms, and Beethoven, FritzReiner, conductor, Van Cliburn, soloist,April 18, 8:15 pm., April 19, 2 pm,April 20, 8:30 pm.Roosevelt University Concert Band,Studebaker Theatre, 410 S. MichiganAve., free, but write for advance tick¬ets, April 22, 8 pm.TheatreGoodman Theatre presents solo ap¬pearance of Burgess Meridith, April 18,19, 20, 8:30 pm. of Forest Hills, New York. Theprize of $2,000 is for his play en¬titled Matty and the Moron andMadonna.The final judge in the contest,Kenneth Tynan, who is dramacritic for the London Observer,stated that Lieberman’s script wonbecause it “took the most risksFilm test next weekThe second Midwest FilmFestival will be held fromd'SS*wSSi'XuwMfSirifS: Al»'n 25 to April 30 as part.XT*"”*: cMcapjAur rf the sixth annual UniversityRoosevelt University Full and Cham- Festival of the Arts (FOTA).her Chorus, selections by Bach, More than seventy films will beshown during the festival in theCLASSIFIED ADSAPTS., ROOMS, ETC.EFFICIENCY apt. unfurn. Call Mrs.Ashley FA 4-1414 until 6 pm or call643-8053. Immediate occupancy.2 LARGE rooms for men in privatehome. Phone, linens. $40 and $30 month.Will exchange part rent for baby sit¬ting. MU 4-5076.SUB LEASE 4 room apt. unfurn. oncampus, $100, 464 during office hours.MODERN 3ta room apt. nicely furn.,clean, tile bath and shower. 5143 Ken¬wood. SO 8-0439.FOR SALEMUST SELL 7,000 books and periodi¬cals in Italian. Latin. Greek. Frenchand German from 16th to 19th cen¬ tury, in the field of humanities, litera¬ture. medicine, law, philosophy and allfields. Archaeological pieces from 2ndcentury B.C. from $1.50 up. Oil paint¬ings and lithographs, old stamped postcards and letters. Open 11 am to 9pm. 2915 W. Cermak Rd. FR 6-6992 or247-1264.GUITAR: Cheap $10. MU 4-9825.PERSONALSPROMPT expert typing at home. 431-2457 1 to 3 pm or DO 3-0466 weekends.TO PLACE a classified ad, call ext.3265 (MI 3-0800). Special student, facul¬ty, and University staff rates.FOUND: one gray cat in Pierce Towermain lounge last week. Contact MarkCoburn, 1907 Pierce. FA 4-9600.14 west randolphchicaao, ill. dearborn 21-1112AttritionFraternities, women’s clubs, organizations, plan to haveyour next luncheon, dinner, or party at Chicago’s newestand smartest supper club and restaurant.Serving complete banquet lunches from $2.45Serving complete banquet dinners from $3.25DINING — DANCING — ENTERTAINMENTfree lunch or dinner to interestedand accredited group representativeSin? itt iflfciifetral In addition to the screenings, thefestival will sponsor a two-dayseries of panel discussions onchanging esthetic and commercialviews of films. On Monday. April29, at 2 and 7 pm, competitionjudges will discuss critical prob¬lems of the “new cinema.” Onnewly-completed Center for Con- April 30, at 2 pm, several Chicagotinuing Education, 1307 E. 60th St. film critics will give their viewson this “new cinema” movementand the critic’s role in relation toit. At 7 pm, the festival will con¬clude with a discussion amongseveral art theater owners on thechanging face of cinema.A special student rate of sixdollars is available for the entireseries of ten programs. Regularseries admission is $12.50, whileadmission to single events is $2for adults, and $1 for students.Information and tickets are avail¬able at the Doc Films office in thebasement of Goodspeed Hall, orext. 2898.HELPWANTED!WE’VE FLIPPEDOUR LIDSTHIS WEEK. . . and are Gterally payingyou to drive our cars away—if you've ever wanted areal deal, you’re crazy tomiss the swinging scene atSouth Side Studebaker thisweek—You name your ownterms — See Steve Nobelnow! Before he runs outof cars.SOUTH SIDE STUDEBAKER, Inc.46th Cottage GroveBO 8-1111 According to Tynan, Lieberman’sdrama is “a really nightmarishversion of life (and death) closingin on a tenement child” which“leaves behind it a bitterly violentimpression of love denied, frus¬trated, misdirected, and destroy¬ed.”Lieberman, 29, who holds a B.S.from City College of New Yorkand an M.A. from Columbia Uni¬versity, is currently an associateeditor in the education departmentof Macmillan Company.University theater usually stagesthe first prize winner of the con¬test and expects to produce Liber¬man's play on campus.The second place prize of $700went to William Linahan. aneditor of Collier’s Encyclojiediafrom New York City. Tynan de¬scribed Linahan’s play, Bianca,as “a first-rate joke, and thecleverest pastiche of Elizabethancomedy I’ve ever read.”Donald C. Spencer, Chairman ofthe Department of Speech andDrama at Gorham State TeachersCollege, Gorham, Maine, won thirdprize for his Ill Wind at Aulis.The Sergei Prize, which offersthe largest sum in prize money($3,000) for full-length originaldramas, was established in 1935by the late Mrs. Anna MeyersSergei in memory of her husband,Charles H. Sergei, founder of theDramatic Publishing Company, toenoourage the writing of newAmerican plays.Mr. "IVDISCOUNT RECORD MARTLISTEN... YOU JAZZ LOVERSIF ... You Haven't Visited Our StoreWe Have Both Lost Money!HUNDREDS OF LP’SBy Getz, Mulligan, Canonball, Taylor, Lateef, Etc.Regular Price — $4.98 & $5.98 $ 4 Q8(Mono or Stereo) INr. “T’s” Discount Record Mart(It's Mr. "TV For Jazz LP's)Corner 47th St. S tnglestde Ave. All Phones: 624-4666FREEH! Present This Ad and Receive $1.00 Cloth orBrush with LP Purchase!TICKETS NOW AVAILABLE DR. A. ZIMBLER, OptometristIN THENEW HYDE PARK SHOPPING CENTER1510 E. 55th St. DO 3-7644EYE EXAMINATIONSPRESCRIPTIONS FILLED CONTACT LENSESNEWEST STYLING IN FRAMESSTUDENT DISCOUNTBLACK FRIARSAside From All That”APRIL 26, 27, 28Student Prices $2.00$1.50MANDEL HALL BOX OFFICE 10 A.M. - 7 P.M.—EXT. 3280 Square root extraction couldn’t be easier than it is on the FridenAutomatic Square Root Calculator. (1) Enter the radicand. (2) Touchone key. The root appears in the dials, automatically correct, withdecimal point in place.You get all the other Friden features, too: automatic positiveand negative division; automatic regular, accumulative, and negativemultiplication; automatic dial clearance; and, for those who needit, optional automatic squaring.Get in touch with us now for purchase or rental of new or usedmachines. We’ll gladly arrange a no-obligation trial.Chicago Broach Office 29 N. Wocher Dr. Tel. 726-8640 FridenApril 14. If 63 • CHICAGO MAROON " 3MorgantKau, others Ginsburg gets College postcirculate petitions Norton S. Ginsburg, profes¬sor in the Department ofHans Morgenthau, Jr.,professor of political sci¬ence, is one of three peoplecurrently engaged in new at¬tempt to solicit support for atreaty calling for the cessation ofnuclear testing.Working along with Morgenthauon the treaty are Dr. David R.Inglis. physicist at Argonne Lab¬oratories, and Ruth Adams, man¬aging editor of the Bulletin of theAtomic Scientists. inferiority no longer exists. If youhave enough weapons to kill everyRussian twice over, what differ¬ence does it make if the Russianscan kill every American onlyonce? Once is enough.”Inglis added that leaflets arebeing distributed along with thepetitions explaining the position oftiie three.Inglis. Morgenthau, and Mrs.Adams have set as their goal aquarter of a million signatures onpetitions they have been circulat¬ing. At present over 10.000 signa¬tures have been received. Thethree leaders plan eventually tomail the full petitions to the Presi¬dent, as well as to senators fromIllinois and Wisconsin.Two types of petitions are beingcirculated, said Mrs. Adams. Oneis aimed at the layman and theother at staffs of colleges and uni¬versities across the country.Commenting on nuclear weaponsand the nuclear age, Morgenthaustated: “There is an enormous gapbetween the truth about nuclearweapons and what most of us thinkabout it. In a nuclear age, diedistinction between superiority andIntramural Scoreboard. 300 from UC on Peace WalksAbout 300 UC students partici¬pated in three Easter Peace walksSaturday. About 40 of 200 personsmarching from Fort Sheridan werefrom UC, estimated a participantfrom the Student Peace Union.Another walk from Stagg Fieldhad about 300 persons, most ofthem from UC.The two walks joined with athiid in the loop. About 130 per¬sons participated in the threewalks. Geography, has been ap¬pointed Associate dean ofthe College.His appointment, effective July1, 1963, was announced by AlanSimpson, Thomas E. DonnelleyProfessor of History and Dean ofthe College.Warner Wick, Dean of Students,had announced his intention toresign as Associate Dean of theCollege several weeks ago.Ginsburg currently is in Indiawhere he is a member of the FordFoundation Consulting Team at¬tached to the Calcutta MetropolitanPlanning Organization.He will continue to teach both inthe Department of Geography andas a member of a new Collegecourse that will be offered oa “TheCity” during the Winter Quarter,1964.Ginsburg has been on the facultysince 1947. He has been a full pro-fesor since I960. He received his BAfrom UC in 1941, his MA here in1947, and his PhD here in 1949.Confab on domestic corpsDr. Kildare’s became all¬university volleyball champsThursday with a surprising21-13, 21-13 victory overTufts N. Cheered on by theirwives, the Kildare’s provided botha powerful spiking attack and atremendous defensive game.Tufts seemed to have lost itsedge after going all out to defeata strong Psi U team 21-10, 21-16.Dr. Kildare’s found a much easiermatch in Psi U-B and coasted toan identical 21-10, 21-16 win.Phi Kappa Psi squeeked pastDodd 21-18, 12-21, 21-13 and claimedthe consolation title. Earlier con¬solation play saw Phi Kappa Psicome from behind to topple theUnderdogs 22-24, 21-12, 21-7 whileDodd took Phi Kappa Psi-B 21-8,20-22, 21-14.Intra-mural baseball begins nextweek. Games will be played Mon¬day through Thursday on both theMidway and North field. In conjuction with the pos¬sible authorization of theNational Service Corps bill inCongress, the College clubsof the Young Democrats of Illinoisis sponsoring a Domestic PeaceCorps Conference.The conference is scheduled tobe held at Loyola University, April27, beginning at 9:30 am. He has written on urban geogra¬phy, p o1it ic a 1 geography, andeconomic development of countriesin East Asia and Southeast Asia.From 1954 to 1956. be served asAssistant Dean of the Division ofSocial Sciences. He was a Fulbrightresearch scholar at the Universitiesof Hong Kong and Malaya in1950-51.At the University, he has servedon the Committee on InternationalRelations; the Committee on FarEastern Civilizations; the Commit¬tee on South Asian Studies, and theCommittee on the Study of NewNations.His most recent activities includeserving as a member of the UnitedNations-Technical Assistance Mis¬sion to Japan on MetropolitanPlanning in the Osaka-Kobe areain 1961 and in 1962; and a con¬sultant to the Calcutta MetropolitanPlanning Organization in 1962 andin 1963. He also is consultant tothe High School Geography Project of the Association of AmericanGeographers and the NationalCouncil on Geographic Education.In April, 1959, he was awardeda “Citation for Meritorious Con¬tribution to the Field of Geogra¬phy’’ by the Association of Ameri¬can Geographers.He served as Director of theAssociation for Asian Studies from1958 to 1961. From 1956 to 1960 hewas Review Editor of the “Annals”of the Association of AmericanGeographers and Actiug Editorfrom 1961 to 1962.Currently he is a member of theEditorial Board of “Economic Development and Cultural Change,”which he joined in 1955; the Com¬mittee on Urbanization. Social Sci¬ence Research Council, which hejoined in 1958; the Joint Committeeon Contemporary China, Social Sci¬ence Research Council and Ameri¬can Council of Learned Societies,which he jdined in 1959.The Conference will be comprisedof addresses by political and com¬munity leaders, a subsequent ques¬tion and answer period, and work¬shops dealing with a variety oftopics.Registration is $1.50. Further in¬formation may be obtained fromJack Jennings, 6024 North MonitorAve., Chicago 46, Ill. WANTED: Conservative Students toForm YAF or Conservative Groups onCampus and to Start a ConservativePaper. Free Literature and Cooperationin Organizing and Planning for BothWill be Supplied Free of Charge.Ttose Interested, Write E. J. McCollum, Jr,P.0. Box 1780, Bridgeport, Conn., orColl EDisen 4-9471 Collect.Meeting: Open Occupancy Committee,UC COKE, Ida Noyes, 7:30 pm.Lectur. aerie*: Law. Religion, and thaState of India. "The Codification and re¬form of Hindu Law" by J. Duncan Der-rett, visiting professor of Indian Lawfrom the University of London, LawBuilding, Room 3, 3:30 pm.Lecture aeries: Personal Contact be¬tween Christians and Moslems lin theMiddle Ages, ‘‘East Christians and Mos¬lems: Personal Experience and OfficialTheory," by Sir Steve Runciman, SocialSciences 122, 4:30 pm.Lecture: ‘‘The Asymptotic Distributionof Eigenvalues of Eilliptic BoundaryValue Problems,'* by Felix Browder,Eckhart 206. 4:30 pm.Class: Elementary Hebrew. Hille!Foundation, 57X5 Woodlawn Avenue,4:45 pm.Film: “The Oriental Institute’s Ex¬pedition to .Nippur, Sacred City ofSumer." by Giorgie Buccellati, spon¬sored by the UC Archaeological Society,3rd floor, Ida Noyes hall, 8 pm.University Theater tryouts for stageadaptation of Huxley's Brave New World,3:30-5:30 pm. Play to ba presentedMay 17, 18, 19.ANCONA SCHOOLMONTESSORI SCHOOLIn Hyde Porkis now accepting applica¬tions forSEPT., 1963Coll PL 2-6359 after 8:00 p.m.MITZIE'SFLOWER SHOPS1225 E. 63rd St.HY 3-53531340 E. 55th St.Ml 3-4020COLOR DEVELOPINGPREPAID MAILERS• mm Roll, 3 mm 20 exp $1.2935 mm, 36 exp $1.91MODEL CAMERA1342 E. 55th HY 3-9259NSA DISCOUNTS■■MOMMiToday s eventsResult: The experimental Ford Mustang,lively 2-seater loaded withsignificant engineering featuresJust under 13 feet long—weight, 1544 pounds, 400 to 700 poundsless than comparable models of popular imported sports jobs—the Mustang is representative of the interesting design chal¬lenges at Ford Motor Company. Unique ways of reducing weightwithout sacrificing strength, to improve performance andeconomy, may stem from its design. ’ »For example, seats are an integral part of the Mustang’s body,^adding structural rigidity. Brake, clutch and accelerator aremounted on a movable cluster which can be adjusted fore andaft (as can the steering wheel) to suit varying sizes of drivers.Other important features: low-drag, aerodynamic shape proven'in the wind tunnel; independent front and rear suspension-; discfront brakes; roll bar built as an integral part of the body/framestructure; hot V-4 engine mounted forward of the rear axle injunit with a 4-speed manual transmission.The Mustang is another example of how challenging assign-’ments met by our engineers and stylists help Ford MotorCompany maintain engineering leadership and provide_newjdeas for the American Road. MOTOR COMPANYThe American Road, Dearborn, MichiganWHERE ENGINEERING LEADERSHIP■RINGS YOU BETTER-BUILT CARS4 • CHICAGO MAROON * April 16. 1963